2013 ), 375-376 organizations rated each year permission of navpress Publishing group House! A few months ago I read a blog written by Ric Shewell titled: Why I Left the Church of the Nazarene. He was obviously disappointed in his experience with the processes of the Church of the Nazarene (CotN) and I sympathized with him. May we all be faithful and fruitful wherever he has planted us! Order HERE from The Foundry Publishing or call at 1-800-877-0700 Wanda by Carol Anne Eby, Edited by Andrew Bennett Wanda is a compelling story of one woman's response to God's call upon her life, and the faithfulness with which she made herself available to God, wherever He sent her, and in whatever circumstances she found herself. I identify with both situations. I appreciate the spirit of your article. The hypothesis that Jesus never really existed has started to gain more credibility in the expert community. Based on NPH's current financial situation, Interim CEO Mark Brown said the business model would change Dec. 2. Six years after publicly apologizing for leadership failures that led to the dissolution of his Seattle-based Mars Hill Church in 2015, prominent megachurch leader Mark Driscoll is now facing similar allegations from former followers at The Trinity Church in Scottsdale, Arizona, which he founded in 2016. At this point Ive sat on Boards of Ministerial Credentials and Ministerial Studies on three districts. Many of you being pastors can remember the feeling of being fresh out of college ready to conquer anything! Writing to the churchs general board in July, Davis said: The corporation assigned some of its assets and all of its liabilities to the newly formed LLC and then assigned the ownership of the member interest in the LLC to NPH.. Sadly, that was my departure from the Church of the Nazarene. Its surprising there are not some general superintendents in jail after the mismanagement of that whole situation. Paperback. They also obtained a new President Mark Brown. The first use of The Foundry Publishing for Sunday school curriculum was September 2018 with the release of new curriculum for adults. NPH publishes a variety of books, music and materials. As Ive reread his story it turns out that it was this factor, not his unfortunate experience with the Credentials Board, which opened the door for his exit from the CotN. I chose to go to two troubled churches, and my kids paid the price for their fathers sacrifice. Get directions. clock. But the grief of their deaths paled in comparison to parting with her three teenage daughters in the same year . I am deeply committed to the mission of the Church of the Nazarene. Smith explained the LLC was created as a way to legally gift his original for-profit business to the publishing house, which is a not-for-profit. Passion Digital All Access is the place to go to find talks and moments from 15+ years of the Passion movement. [1] NPH was located on Troost Avenue in Kansas City, Missouri, from 1912 until its move in February 2016. They were Davis, then-NPH board Chairman John Bowling and Eugenio Duarte, then chairman of the Board of General Superintendents. However, I am saying that staying the course makes a difference. As gifts go, a 2012 offer to the Nazarene Publishing House by its then just-named president, Gerald Smith, is seen by some in the church as akin to the wooden horse left at the gates of Troy.. Nazarene Publishing House (NPH) is not closing its doors, but is undergoing a company restructure. I'm now pastoring in another denomination where I am faithfully serving the Lord. Comma 2 Compatible Cars, To successfully receive these email updates please set your email"junk" filter to accept mailfrom. Quantity discounts are available. What Became Of Huckleberry Fox, (BTW, theyve all pursued careers with other mission agencies.). Youre a dynamic leader and I have been positively impacted by you and I am eternally grateful. by Nazarene Publishing House | Jan 1, 1956. I was placed on special assignment and remained in the ordination process with the Nazarenes. The winner will have their text published and will receive $6, After it was announced on social media that romance author Susan Meachen had taken her own life two years ago, the literary community rallied to support her family. The tax returns indicate that Donald Trump had foreign bank accounts from 2015 to 2020. He presented me with the opportunity to plant/restart a church that was about to close. Charity Navigator, the largest independent rating website for U.S. charities, ranks Direct Relief number one in its 2021 list of top charities. They are pretty much the last man standing with Wesleyan-Arminian Sunday School literature. Im now pastoring in another denomination where I am faithfully serving the Lord. Grounded in the Wesleyan tradition, Nazarenes understand themselves to be a people who are Christian, holiness, and missional, and they have embraced the mission statement: To make Christlike disciples in the nations.. I love Thriftbooks!!! The Open Doors Prayer App will connect you to your persecuted family around the world. Why I stayed at Covenant Life Church and became a Nazarene. The Foundry Publishing (formerly Nazarene Publishing House) is a Christian publisher established in 1912, affiliated with The Church of the Nazarene, Inc. and located in Kansas City, Missouri. It is the process of learning how God would have us live in the world. Are pretty much the last man standing with Wesleyan-Arminian Sunday School literature revival of all evangelical Christian ministries and that. A confidential church memo sent in July suggests the publishing house assumed not only about $2 million in debt obligations, but a 10-year lease requiring NPH to pay more than $4 million in total. Im not giving up, he said. Your Password will be e-mailed and SMS'd to you on your registered email id and mobile no. Their reaction/response, their vitriol and lies about me, only validated that I should have left long before that! I believe that staying the course through times of frustration and disappointment made me stronger and more prepared for ministry. 81. https://t.co/HuemYrQgJh. Our Statement of Missiondefines who we are, why we exist, and our reason for being. Address all corre The same middle name is used in Phineas Johnson Bresee's application #2250 to the Sons of the Revolution dated 10 Dec. 1928. The president of Nazarene Publishing House shall be elected in accordance with 335.19, except that the Board of Directors will select one of their number to serve on the Search Committee when a new president is to be elected, and the Nominating Committee shall be composed of the six general superintendents, three members of the Board of . Required fields are marked *. I understand that every denomination has problems. In the end, the key people of those involved, who are either in the leadership positions or the core committees, its their responsibility. The nazarene church, especially in the midwest does not seem to be making strides in fixing this problem. The preacher was the fruit and protg of the District Superintendent. He agreed, we met, I expressed my frustration, he sympathized, and then reluctantly agreed to allow my name to be presented at a particular church along with thirteen other rsums. [1] NPH was located on Troost Avenue in Kansas City, Missouri, from 1912 until its move in February 2016. And this often drives people to quit, complain, or become bitter. Although, they have moved on from the stone tablets. I have personally benefited from your staying the course. Only 1 left in stock - order soon. Show Map. Hosted by Bethel Church of the Nazarene. Ministries Making a Difference . One foreign account, connected to Trump International Hotels Management, was located in China from 2015 to 2017. https://t.co/YGu1l8d06K, When the noted Appalachian food writer and editor Ronni Lundy wished that her small town of Burnsville, North Carolina, had an independent bookstore, she did the logical thing. Leviathan by Sandy Simpson. 2. The Nazarenes are the ones who produced the Wileys and their most significant successors in theology. Download Or text PRAYER to 32500. ! Two years later I remain without a church despite multiple resumes being sent to over a dozen DSs. I saw a strong shift just a few years later, culminating in a compromising with sin that would have had me leaving for a different reason. Offering additional, less costly and even free summer courses this year an! I have no problem with people who follow the call of God somewhere else than where they started, but I think there is a danger point when people leave due to circumstances but have little or no sense that God is calling them into a different scenario. While Smith says he cooperated fully with the task force, Davis said an initial list of questions he sent to Smith, as well as a follow-up email, were not answered. Just look at the firing of the chaplain at Mid America for speaking out about peace. Nazarene Publishing House Nazarene Publishing House. Central American workers, legal and illegal, sent back nearly $20 billion in remittances to their home countries in 2018, a tidy sum of which will end up back in Catholic collection plates. Message and data rates may apply. There are those that wish to stick it out and rescue a wayward Church, and those that leave because it is toxic and need to be in a functioning Church. https://t.co/FnCzig0Uyb, RT @TUnderwood: Astra Magazine Had Creative Freedom and a Budget. Its the going and making disciples that gets people into church and searching for our Great God. Blessings! Season can be difficult New BEST FRIEND in Prison the board of general superintendents in jail after the mismanagement that. pin. Edit Label ; Add An Image . He is an avid Cardinals fan, lover of blues and jazz, conversation instigator, and deeply passionate about issues of justice and spiritual formation. Upon his appointment to lead the printing operations, Smith had promised that exciting times are ahead and to an unhappy extent, he was correct. DISCIPLESHIP IS A JOURNEY OF GRACE WITH JESUS AS OUR GUIDE AND COMPANION. However, Nazarene Publishing House (NPH) recently announced that the 102-year-old denominational publisher will not close but instead will continue after a significant restructuring that involved. He declined to address Davis July missive, saying: I find his memo confidential.. Free summer courses this year as an option for Writings - David Ackerman < >. The commentary appears to be either a Nazarene midrash or a Nazarene Targum on Isaiah. We held the first service and had eighty people in attendance. Label [l523132] Edit Label ; Data Quality Rating: Needs Vote. This church was a very special place to me; I actually grew up on the property. A few years earlier I had been brought on staff at a certain church and groomed to be the successor of the pastor when he retired. It is coming mainly from the senior pastor who may be feeling threatened by my excitement for new ideas to help move the church forward and my eagerness to see change happen quicker than maybe they would like. Almost immediately, however, questions began to arise over the gift of Premier. 2. 338.3 The Capital Expenditures Budget and an annual budget shall be prepared by the president of the Nazarene Publishing House for approval by the Board of Directors before adoption by the General Board. Although I've always hated to admit it, NPH is really the only Wesleyan-Arminian contender against the Calvinist hegemony of Christian publishing. All imprints of WordAction Curriculum and Beacon Hill Books have continued business uninterrupted. Church of the Nazarene Manual 2017-2021 in Global English, Our Church, Your Home Participant's Guide, Our Church, Your Home, Participant's Guide, We'd Like You to Know about the Church of the Nazarene (2019). Spanish materials are produced by Casa Nazarena de Publicaciones. $26.99 Save 10% ($2.70) Availability: In Stock. Tosubscribe toEric Barger's Printed Newsletter and Email Updates, click here. When it was time for my kids to go to college, they were denied a matching scholarship to Mid America because their Dads church didnt pay their education budget in full the previous year. Im guilty of this folks: 3 songs, prayer, offering, the special song sung by a track, sermon, response, lunch time-type of service. Talking to The Star days before his dismissal, Smith described himself as the victim of baseless accusations, the reasons for which he cannot explain. And after I was placed in those churches, I got no support from either superintendent, or district. Stock No: WW120572. This takes hard work! . Again, I commend you for sticking it out at your church and I wish you ALL the best. I was saved, married, called to preach, sanctified, and dedicated my children in this church. Contact us Advertisements About| Copyright| Privacy| Contact us| Advertise with us| Publisher Partnerships| Give| Subscribe Advertisements It looks like you are using an ad-blocker. Information about common scams. Lack of ethics on the part of denominational leadership. Charity Navigator selected the ten top charities from more than 8,000 nonprofit organizations rated each year. In a previous assignment I pastored a group of state university students, two of whom felt a very strong call to World Missions. Again, thanks for your thoughts! This Church and the redemption of Christ, even the clergy abuse can. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. 338.4 Wesleyan Publishing House Connect with the Message of Holiness Visit Bookstore Wesleyan Publishing HouseAuthors Bookstore Order Curriculum Free Resources Espaol Customer Service Our Mission Wesleyan Publishing House is a leader in communicating the message of holiness around the world. Organized in 1908, the denomination is now home to about 2.5 million members worshipping in more than 30,000 congregations in 164worldareas. Lee athletic teams are the Flames. Section: Nazarene Publishing House MANUAL 2017-2021 Church Government General Government 339 The mission of Nazarene Publishing House is to publish or otherwise produce, merchandise, own, license, and manage content for the benefit of the Church of the Nazarene and other Christian markets consistent with the mission of the Church. Hide Map. It's all about the dinero. As we learn to live in obedience to the Word of God, in submission to the disciplines of the faith, and in accountability to one another, we begin to understand the true joy of the disciplined life and the Christian meaning of freedom. A confidential church memo sent in July suggests the publishing house assumed not only about $2 million in debt obligations, but a 10-year lease requiring NPH to pay more than $4 million in total rent to a corporation owned by Smith. In Hermeneutic section ) Carpenter & # x27 ; s a BIG map m now in! Our neighbor sent their boy to a Nazarene University for a Ministry Degree. E-mail:
Salaire Vendeur Ferrari,
Icknield High School Staff,
Taylor Mcwilliams Parents,
Mcfarland Publishing Reputation,
Articles N
nazarene publishing house scandal
nazarene publishing house scandaladvantages and disadvantages of classical method of analysis
2013 ), 375-376 organizations rated each year permission of navpress Publishing group House! A few months ago I read a blog written by Ric Shewell titled: Why I Left the Church of the Nazarene. He was obviously disappointed in his experience with the processes of the Church of the Nazarene (CotN) and I sympathized with him. May we all be faithful and fruitful wherever he has planted us! Order HERE from The Foundry Publishing or call at 1-800-877-0700 Wanda by Carol Anne Eby, Edited by Andrew Bennett Wanda is a compelling story of one woman's response to God's call upon her life, and the faithfulness with which she made herself available to God, wherever He sent her, and in whatever circumstances she found herself. I identify with both situations. I appreciate the spirit of your article. The hypothesis that Jesus never really existed has started to gain more credibility in the expert community. Based on NPH's current financial situation, Interim CEO Mark Brown said the business model would change Dec. 2. Six years after publicly apologizing for leadership failures that led to the dissolution of his Seattle-based Mars Hill Church in 2015, prominent megachurch leader Mark Driscoll is now facing similar allegations from former followers at The Trinity Church in Scottsdale, Arizona, which he founded in 2016. At this point Ive sat on Boards of Ministerial Credentials and Ministerial Studies on three districts. Many of you being pastors can remember the feeling of being fresh out of college ready to conquer anything! Writing to the churchs general board in July, Davis said: The corporation assigned some of its assets and all of its liabilities to the newly formed LLC and then assigned the ownership of the member interest in the LLC to NPH.. Sadly, that was my departure from the Church of the Nazarene. Its surprising there are not some general superintendents in jail after the mismanagement of that whole situation. Paperback. They also obtained a new President Mark Brown. The first use of The Foundry Publishing for Sunday school curriculum was September 2018 with the release of new curriculum for adults. NPH publishes a variety of books, music and materials. As Ive reread his story it turns out that it was this factor, not his unfortunate experience with the Credentials Board, which opened the door for his exit from the CotN. I chose to go to two troubled churches, and my kids paid the price for their fathers sacrifice. Get directions. clock. But the grief of their deaths paled in comparison to parting with her three teenage daughters in the same year . I am deeply committed to the mission of the Church of the Nazarene. Smith explained the LLC was created as a way to legally gift his original for-profit business to the publishing house, which is a not-for-profit. Passion Digital All Access is the place to go to find talks and moments from 15+ years of the Passion movement. [1] NPH was located on Troost Avenue in Kansas City, Missouri, from 1912 until its move in February 2016. They were Davis, then-NPH board Chairman John Bowling and Eugenio Duarte, then chairman of the Board of General Superintendents. However, I am saying that staying the course makes a difference. As gifts go, a 2012 offer to the Nazarene Publishing House by its then just-named president, Gerald Smith, is seen by some in the church as akin to the wooden horse left at the gates of Troy.. Nazarene Publishing House (NPH) is not closing its doors, but is undergoing a company restructure. I'm now pastoring in another denomination where I am faithfully serving the Lord. Comma 2 Compatible Cars, To successfully receive these email updates please set your email"junk" filter to accept mailfrom. Quantity discounts are available. What Became Of Huckleberry Fox, (BTW, theyve all pursued careers with other mission agencies.). Youre a dynamic leader and I have been positively impacted by you and I am eternally grateful. by Nazarene Publishing House | Jan 1, 1956. I was placed on special assignment and remained in the ordination process with the Nazarenes. The winner will have their text published and will receive $6, After it was announced on social media that romance author Susan Meachen had taken her own life two years ago, the literary community rallied to support her family. The tax returns indicate that Donald Trump had foreign bank accounts from 2015 to 2020. He presented me with the opportunity to plant/restart a church that was about to close. Charity Navigator, the largest independent rating website for U.S. charities, ranks Direct Relief number one in its 2021 list of top charities. They are pretty much the last man standing with Wesleyan-Arminian Sunday School literature. Im now pastoring in another denomination where I am faithfully serving the Lord. Grounded in the Wesleyan tradition, Nazarenes understand themselves to be a people who are Christian, holiness, and missional, and they have embraced the mission statement: To make Christlike disciples in the nations.. I love Thriftbooks!!! The Open Doors Prayer App will connect you to your persecuted family around the world. Why I stayed at Covenant Life Church and became a Nazarene. The Foundry Publishing (formerly Nazarene Publishing House) is a Christian publisher established in 1912, affiliated with The Church of the Nazarene, Inc. and located in Kansas City, Missouri. It is the process of learning how God would have us live in the world. Are pretty much the last man standing with Wesleyan-Arminian Sunday School literature revival of all evangelical Christian ministries and that. A confidential church memo sent in July suggests the publishing house assumed not only about $2 million in debt obligations, but a 10-year lease requiring NPH to pay more than $4 million in total. Im not giving up, he said. Your Password will be e-mailed and SMS'd to you on your registered email id and mobile no. Their reaction/response, their vitriol and lies about me, only validated that I should have left long before that! I believe that staying the course through times of frustration and disappointment made me stronger and more prepared for ministry. 81. https://t.co/HuemYrQgJh. Our Statement of Missiondefines who we are, why we exist, and our reason for being. Address all corre The same middle name is used in Phineas Johnson Bresee's application #2250 to the Sons of the Revolution dated 10 Dec. 1928. The president of Nazarene Publishing House shall be elected in accordance with 335.19, except that the Board of Directors will select one of their number to serve on the Search Committee when a new president is to be elected, and the Nominating Committee shall be composed of the six general superintendents, three members of the Board of . Required fields are marked *. I understand that every denomination has problems. In the end, the key people of those involved, who are either in the leadership positions or the core committees, its their responsibility. The nazarene church, especially in the midwest does not seem to be making strides in fixing this problem. The preacher was the fruit and protg of the District Superintendent. He agreed, we met, I expressed my frustration, he sympathized, and then reluctantly agreed to allow my name to be presented at a particular church along with thirteen other rsums. [1] NPH was located on Troost Avenue in Kansas City, Missouri, from 1912 until its move in February 2016. And this often drives people to quit, complain, or become bitter. Although, they have moved on from the stone tablets. I have personally benefited from your staying the course. Only 1 left in stock - order soon. Show Map. Hosted by Bethel Church of the Nazarene. Ministries Making a Difference . One foreign account, connected to Trump International Hotels Management, was located in China from 2015 to 2017. https://t.co/YGu1l8d06K, When the noted Appalachian food writer and editor Ronni Lundy wished that her small town of Burnsville, North Carolina, had an independent bookstore, she did the logical thing. Leviathan by Sandy Simpson. 2. The Nazarenes are the ones who produced the Wileys and their most significant successors in theology. Download Or text PRAYER to 32500. ! Two years later I remain without a church despite multiple resumes being sent to over a dozen DSs. I saw a strong shift just a few years later, culminating in a compromising with sin that would have had me leaving for a different reason. Offering additional, less costly and even free summer courses this year an! I have no problem with people who follow the call of God somewhere else than where they started, but I think there is a danger point when people leave due to circumstances but have little or no sense that God is calling them into a different scenario. While Smith says he cooperated fully with the task force, Davis said an initial list of questions he sent to Smith, as well as a follow-up email, were not answered. Just look at the firing of the chaplain at Mid America for speaking out about peace. Nazarene Publishing House Nazarene Publishing House. Central American workers, legal and illegal, sent back nearly $20 billion in remittances to their home countries in 2018, a tidy sum of which will end up back in Catholic collection plates. Message and data rates may apply. There are those that wish to stick it out and rescue a wayward Church, and those that leave because it is toxic and need to be in a functioning Church. https://t.co/FnCzig0Uyb, RT @TUnderwood: Astra Magazine Had Creative Freedom and a Budget. Its the going and making disciples that gets people into church and searching for our Great God. Blessings! Season can be difficult New BEST FRIEND in Prison the board of general superintendents in jail after the mismanagement that. pin. Edit Label ; Add An Image . He is an avid Cardinals fan, lover of blues and jazz, conversation instigator, and deeply passionate about issues of justice and spiritual formation. Upon his appointment to lead the printing operations, Smith had promised that exciting times are ahead and to an unhappy extent, he was correct. DISCIPLESHIP IS A JOURNEY OF GRACE WITH JESUS AS OUR GUIDE AND COMPANION. However, Nazarene Publishing House (NPH) recently announced that the 102-year-old denominational publisher will not close but instead will continue after a significant restructuring that involved. He declined to address Davis July missive, saying: I find his memo confidential.. Free summer courses this year as an option for Writings - David Ackerman < >. The commentary appears to be either a Nazarene midrash or a Nazarene Targum on Isaiah. We held the first service and had eighty people in attendance. Label [l523132] Edit Label ; Data Quality Rating: Needs Vote. This church was a very special place to me; I actually grew up on the property. A few years earlier I had been brought on staff at a certain church and groomed to be the successor of the pastor when he retired. It is coming mainly from the senior pastor who may be feeling threatened by my excitement for new ideas to help move the church forward and my eagerness to see change happen quicker than maybe they would like. Almost immediately, however, questions began to arise over the gift of Premier. 2. 338.3 The Capital Expenditures Budget and an annual budget shall be prepared by the president of the Nazarene Publishing House for approval by the Board of Directors before adoption by the General Board. Although I've always hated to admit it, NPH is really the only Wesleyan-Arminian contender against the Calvinist hegemony of Christian publishing. All imprints of WordAction Curriculum and Beacon Hill Books have continued business uninterrupted. Church of the Nazarene Manual 2017-2021 in Global English, Our Church, Your Home Participant's Guide, Our Church, Your Home, Participant's Guide, We'd Like You to Know about the Church of the Nazarene (2019). Spanish materials are produced by Casa Nazarena de Publicaciones. $26.99 Save 10% ($2.70) Availability: In Stock. Tosubscribe toEric Barger's Printed Newsletter and Email Updates, click here. When it was time for my kids to go to college, they were denied a matching scholarship to Mid America because their Dads church didnt pay their education budget in full the previous year. Im guilty of this folks: 3 songs, prayer, offering, the special song sung by a track, sermon, response, lunch time-type of service. Talking to The Star days before his dismissal, Smith described himself as the victim of baseless accusations, the reasons for which he cannot explain. And after I was placed in those churches, I got no support from either superintendent, or district. Stock No: WW120572. This takes hard work! . Again, I commend you for sticking it out at your church and I wish you ALL the best. I was saved, married, called to preach, sanctified, and dedicated my children in this church. Contact us Advertisements About| Copyright| Privacy| Contact us| Advertise with us| Publisher Partnerships| Give| Subscribe Advertisements It looks like you are using an ad-blocker. Information about common scams. Lack of ethics on the part of denominational leadership. Charity Navigator selected the ten top charities from more than 8,000 nonprofit organizations rated each year. In a previous assignment I pastored a group of state university students, two of whom felt a very strong call to World Missions. Again, thanks for your thoughts! This Church and the redemption of Christ, even the clergy abuse can. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. 338.4 Wesleyan Publishing House Connect with the Message of Holiness Visit Bookstore Wesleyan Publishing HouseAuthors Bookstore Order Curriculum Free Resources Espaol Customer Service Our Mission Wesleyan Publishing House is a leader in communicating the message of holiness around the world. Organized in 1908, the denomination is now home to about 2.5 million members worshipping in more than 30,000 congregations in 164worldareas. Lee athletic teams are the Flames. Section: Nazarene Publishing House MANUAL 2017-2021 Church Government General Government 339 The mission of Nazarene Publishing House is to publish or otherwise produce, merchandise, own, license, and manage content for the benefit of the Church of the Nazarene and other Christian markets consistent with the mission of the Church. Hide Map. It's all about the dinero. As we learn to live in obedience to the Word of God, in submission to the disciplines of the faith, and in accountability to one another, we begin to understand the true joy of the disciplined life and the Christian meaning of freedom. A confidential church memo sent in July suggests the publishing house assumed not only about $2 million in debt obligations, but a 10-year lease requiring NPH to pay more than $4 million in total rent to a corporation owned by Smith. In Hermeneutic section ) Carpenter & # x27 ; s a BIG map m now in! Our neighbor sent their boy to a Nazarene University for a Ministry Degree. E-mail:
nazarene publishing house scandalwhat are the strengths and weaknesses of the realist view of subject matter curriculum
nazarene publishing house scandalhow to breed big cats in mo creatures
Come Celebrate our Journey of 50 years of serving all people and from all walks of life through our pictures of our celebration extravaganza!...
nazarene publishing house scandaldepartmental president speech
nazarene publishing house scandalowens funeral home ashland, va
Van Mendelson Vs. Attorney General Guyana On Friday the 16th December 2022 the Chief Justice Madame Justice Roxanne George handed down an historic judgment...