Unlike the Since EPA's invoices must be on a period of performance basis, the contractor shall have a completion invoice for each year of the period of performance. Supplemental Terms. The content of the responses is entirely from reviewers. (4) Requisition Number and Date - Leave blank. (6) Articles or Services - Insert the contract number as in the Standard Form 1034. If so then you would probably not be eating out but instead, going to the grocery store for the ingredients to make it yourself at home. If you do not believe or agree with the bill, your recourse is to refuse to pay and then either settle with the contractor for some mutually agreeable amount, or wait for the contractor to take legal action, at which point you can use the legal process of \"discovery\" (e.g. So you got a contract estimate for your kitchen remodeling project or bathroom renovation. 1. Some contractors are ok with this. subpoenas; interrogatories, which are written questions; notices to produce documents) to obtain information as to cost, to attempt to prove that the bill was unjustified. advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or The itemized list lets me make choices like "granite counter for $2K? Note to paragraph (h) - Amounts claimed on vouchers must be based on records maintained by the contractor to show by major cost element the amounts claimed for reimbursement for each applicable contract. After the total amount claimed, provide summary dollar amounts disallowed on the contract as of the date of the invoice. Free Advice is a unit of Quote.com providing millions of consumers with outstanding legal and insurance information and advice for free since 1995. Due to system limitations, the invoice number cannot be more than 11 characters to include spaces. 0000000016 00000 n I did use the contractor's suggested vendors because they already had experience working well together. After any conversation with your contractor, write an email with the key bullet points. 248 I was fortunate that each of the vendors* still gave me the invoice for my selections so I could see exactly what I was spending. "}}]}, Asked on December 12, 2011 under Business Law, Indiana. 0000007638 00000 n I have a list from the decorator. These included the plans that were going to be submitted to the City in order to get the permit. The contractor was fine with that since I had already done my research and had selected all my appliances and finishes. Uncontested in Texas in which I deeded over the home to my Ex.I am the signer and he is co.It has been eight years and now I am ready to purchase a home however I am still on this note how can I work around this? including an itemized bill with the following information: Date of service, . Not just a $10K adder for "materials.". (6) Contractor Acquired Software (if authorized by the contract) - Identify by item the quantities, unit prices, and total dollars billed. endstream endobj 297 0 obj <>/Size 271/Type/XRef>>stream For example, we have an allowance for $940 for backsplash tile and grout. But he would not even start the demo until I had everything on site - he wanted to get in and get out without worrying about delivery issues which I understand. No but if I see that the estimate is way out of line with other estimates or with known costs then I am going to question it. Don't trust the bill. On the other hand, a budget granite can be had for about the same price as cultured marble. As long as the scope of work and budget align with the expectations, that should be more than enough. (3) Subcontracts - Identify the major cost elements for each subcontract. 9 Romford Member since 29 Jul 2011 The current Medicare manual requirement instructs Medicare contractors (carriers and MACs) to provide education to the providers and suppliers explaining the . I want an invoice as proof of the works his company did and as a security should there be any issues later on. We charge $75 an hour for itemization and your job will take between six and eight hours to compile such an estimate. Electronic invoicing and the Invoice Processing Platform (IPP). I have no desire to deal with someone who wants to hide his 500% markup on granite, for example. AV Preeminent: The highest peer rating standard. Standard Form 1034, Public Voucher for Purchases and Services other than Personal, is prescribed for used by contractors to show the amount claimed for reimbursement. They prefer to ask about your allowance and then direct you to the row of slabs that are in that price "range" without telling you specific prices. Standard Form 1035, Public Voucher for Purchases and Services other than Personal - Continuation Sheet, is prescribed for use to furnish the necessary supporting detail or additional information required by the Contracting Officer. If you ask, we aren't right for each other. Always be wary of contractors that advertise free home repair estimates or contract estimates. But even if not - if everything is on the up-and-up, and if the customer is being billed as set out by the contract or agreement to perform work, then there should be little harm in showing a customer the receipts for materials. It must be completely obvious, maybe use a large bold font. The vast majority of contractors are hardworking, trustworthy people, but just like in any profession, some individuals may overcharge you. (1) The charges for subcontracts shall be further detailed in a supporting schedule showing the major cost elements for each subcontract. It's much less important to know the allocation of $ for each of the details. If he is a reputable contractor, he would give you an itemized bill without you even having to ask. 0000003405 00000 n Talk to their references, get a detailed quote, andbefore the project beginsa contract. (7) Travel - When travel costs exceed $2,000 per invoice period, identify by trip, the number of travelers, the duration of travel, the point of origin, destination, purpose of trip, transportation by unit price, per diem rates on daily basis and total dollars billed. I would suggest you get a quantity surveyor in to assess the values of the works done, and if its to standard, has BCO been round to inspect and sign of the works. HWn}WH@&noExl`jILx6e>Ul^dd_]31/Ib]`A$QAV.V7_-^H7W5 If a job takes a day longer i might loose a bit but thats life..Only time i charge more is for plastering as sometimes its quoted for 25mm and any more than that will cost. (nope the supplier delivers anything over 50 sheets for free), then it was well we have to go order it and on and on with inane reasons to justify the price. If a contractor can manage a 500% markup on anything in a fixed bid and still meet your bottom line (unlikely) then he's losing his shirt on another component of that bid. Invoices or requests for contract financing payment must clearly indicate the period of performance for which payment is requested. Riddled with charges and no explanation for what they are for. Notify the contractor in writing that the provider or supplier refused to submit a claim to . feedback. Final Vouchers shall be submitted if finalized rates have been received for the entire period of performance. The law does not specifically require an itemized bill. 0000004249 00000 n Let the person quoting you the price make the suggestions first. I regret not getting better itemization from my contractor before starting the project. You in essence gave the contractor a \"blank check\" by having him do work without an estimate, proposal, or some maximum cap to cost. or an attorney's conclusion. This information should be obtained through a means which maintains subcontractor confidentiality (for example, via sealed envelopes), if the subcontractor expresses Confidential Business Information (CBI) concerns. It's a lot of work to put together a quote and so I can kind of see where they are coming from. trailer xbbf`b``3 _m As an example, company A might charge $150 for a specific part, which includes a 20% markup. Need help identifying this baby furniture item? (ii) Under this contract, the following documents are required to be submitted as an attachment to the IPP invoice: (This is a fill-in for acceptable types of required documentation, such as an SF 1034 and 1035, or an invoice/self-designed form on company letterhead that contains the required information.). What can be done to you for not paying court costs by a certain date? My markup and supplier discounts are none of theirs. Some balk at doing it, but some don't.They weren't super detailed, but for example the countertops line item said something like "natural stone counter up to $XX/sqft with basic edge detail installed with cutouts for sinks and faucets - $XXX"Some of the other line items were drywall/painting, electrical, plumbing, demo, shower door, tiling (labor and materials, excluding the tile itself), cabinetry.Whether they are itemized or not, try to get a fairly detailed quote for the work being done. If you drag your feet on paying, your contractor may become frustrated and file a lien against your home. If you have a written contract with your contractor or even a text exchange, look back at your agreement. Also, as a contractor you can screw yourself by giving out to much information. This includes the costs that our AHS warranty covers. You wont get any money back, you should have got at least 3 prices, checked all their credentials, insurances, how long they have been trading and seen some of their works. 1. Do I always want a line item for materials? EPA Invoice Preparation Instructions - SF 1035. I can't remember the name, but no not just drywall. You want to be sure they're charging you what they should and find a solution where you both feel comfortable. Request for pricing and shipping - teak and glass dining table. feedback, sorry to hear of your problems, firstly you need to send him a letter by registered post asking clearly for a receipt of all the work and state a time scale for a reply(14 days is acceptable) keep a copy of your letter, if he fails to reply contact inland revenue as he is not paying tax, mention in your letter that you will do this. That is pretty much an automatic out in my book. feedback. When I did my kitchen, I purchased everything myself except the cabinets. Insert COST REIMBURSABLE - FINAL VOUCHER or INDEFINITE QUANTITY/INDEFINITE DELIVERY - FINAL VOUCHER on the final public voucher. "maybe talk to trading standards as i find it also strange how his price doubled! Don't pay cash on anything over a couple of hundred pounds without a receipt, it's not traceable. The extra is for fabricating. 0000001293 00000 n Notable: This rating indicates that the lawyer has been recognized by a large number of their peers for strong ethical standards. Adjustment vouchers should be submitted if finalized indirect rates were received but the rates are not for the entire period of performance. Time is money. However, scanned documents are acceptable when they are part of a submission of a payment request made using Invoice Processing Platform or another electronic form authorized by the Contracting Officer. (iv) Contractor assistance with enrollment can be obtained by contacting the IPP Production Helpdesk via email at IPPCustomerSupport@fiscal.treasury.gov or by telephone at (866) 973-3131. (5) Number and Date of Order - Insert payee's name and address as in the Standard Form 1034. 97% positive The Contracting Officer may request an audit of the completion vouchers before final payment is made. A construction invoice is a document that contractors use to provide an itemized bill to an individual or company to which they have provided services and/or supplies. Now my builder is refusing to give me a detailed invoice - in fact he won't provide any invoice at all. Would you order a burger at a restaurant ask them to break down the price of the lettuce, tomato, bun, pickle, burger, ketchup, mustard and mayonnaise? (5) Voucher Number - Insert the appropriate serial number of the voucher. 0000008416 00000 n Thankfully it does not happen often and for the most part people are reasonable but there is always the few bad apples. Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you. 99% positive With the info you have posted, its highly unlikely you will get any official receipts/gaurantees for the work. 3 attorney answers Posted on Apr 18, 2012 Your fact pattern indicates numerous violations by the contractor, including violations of the Consumer Fraud Act, which could expose him to additional damages. This actually violated the rules governing federal bankruptcy cases, which require creditors presenting a proof of claim to provide an "itemized statement.". So that I can file a claim regarding injury that occurred on our my property under phase of construction. 3. (13) Quantity; Unit Price - Insert for supply contracts. Consider negotiating any aspects that you feel are unfair or unnecessarily expensive. Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save. feedback, its the old saying pay cheap pay twice 12000 was not a realistic quote in the first place ,afraid you will need to put this down to experience ,beware of cheap imitations. There is a cost associated with that, and when you start comparing every item to the Amazon price, he knows he will lose. These ratings indicate attorneys who are widely respected by their peers for their ethical standards and legal expertise in a specific area of practice. Answered on Jan 24th, 2013 at 10:42 PM If he is a reputable contractor, he would give you an itemized bill without you even having to ask. Work contracts include start and end dates, payment plans, and several clauses intended to protect consumers. I hope this is taken in the spirit it is given, I really don't think you and Treb are saying anything different, except that you're saying you have the right to the info necessary to justify the higher bid AFTER you've received the bid, and he's saying you should have vetted him and his work BEFORE you even asked him to bid (so you'd already know the answer - that his seams and edging will be perfect; and you should have vetted the other guy too so you'd know whether his will or won't be). Can I file a civil lawsuit myself without a help of an attorney? 2. What relationship did you agree to? Not because I want the cheapest price but because I want to justify the higher price. I would see a solicitor to be honest, legally there should be a contract, or a written/verbal agreement between you and the builder. Partnership is a great word. The manner of breakdown, e.g., task order/delivery order basis with/without separate program management, contract period will be specified in the contract instructions. What can I do? Don't ask the contractor to provide you with something that you are not willing to pay for. (5) Contractor Acquired Equipment - Identify by item the quantities, unit prices, and total dollars billed. Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers, Outdoor Lighting & Audio/Visual Specialists. I know those prices. Photo: Sam Edwards/ Caia Image / Adobe Stock. Should your contractor sue you for your nonpayment, you would certainly have defenses to the claims, given the lack of notice of the increased costs and intentional overspending. You have received finalized rates for the entire base period that encompass both fiscal years that cover the base period. If I contract to build a house for you for $50k, that's what you need to know. That is more transparent as to pricing for individual components. ________________________________________________________________.
Westrock Employee Handbook,
Military Dogs Reunited,
Icw Racing Rims Lug Nut Key,
Steve Wright In The Afternoon Characters,
Articles C
contractor refuses to provide itemized bill
by contractor refuses to provide itemized billwhat is the most important component of hospital culture
Unlike the Since EPA's invoices must be on a period of performance basis, the contractor shall have a completion invoice for each year of the period of performance. Supplemental Terms. The content of the responses is entirely from reviewers. (4) Requisition Number and Date - Leave blank. (6) Articles or Services - Insert the contract number as in the Standard Form 1034. If so then you would probably not be eating out but instead, going to the grocery store for the ingredients to make it yourself at home. If you do not believe or agree with the bill, your recourse is to refuse to pay and then either settle with the contractor for some mutually agreeable amount, or wait for the contractor to take legal action, at which point you can use the legal process of \"discovery\" (e.g. So you got a contract estimate for your kitchen remodeling project or bathroom renovation. 1. Some contractors are ok with this. subpoenas; interrogatories, which are written questions; notices to produce documents) to obtain information as to cost, to attempt to prove that the bill was unjustified. advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or The itemized list lets me make choices like "granite counter for $2K? Note to paragraph (h) - Amounts claimed on vouchers must be based on records maintained by the contractor to show by major cost element the amounts claimed for reimbursement for each applicable contract. After the total amount claimed, provide summary dollar amounts disallowed on the contract as of the date of the invoice. Free Advice is a unit of Quote.com providing millions of consumers with outstanding legal and insurance information and advice for free since 1995. Due to system limitations, the invoice number cannot be more than 11 characters to include spaces. 0000000016 00000 n
I did use the contractor's suggested vendors because they already had experience working well together. After any conversation with your contractor, write an email with the key bullet points. 248 I was fortunate that each of the vendors* still gave me the invoice for my selections so I could see exactly what I was spending. "}}]}, Asked on December 12, 2011 under Business Law, Indiana. 0000007638 00000 n
I have a list from the decorator. These included the plans that were going to be submitted to the City in order to get the permit. The contractor was fine with that since I had already done my research and had selected all my appliances and finishes. Uncontested in Texas in which I deeded over the home to my Ex.I am the signer and he is co.It has been eight years and now I am ready to purchase a home however I am still on this note how can I work around this? including an itemized bill with the following information: Date of service, . Not just a $10K adder for "materials.". (6) Contractor Acquired Software (if authorized by the contract) - Identify by item the quantities, unit prices, and total dollars billed. endstream
endobj
297 0 obj
<>/Size 271/Type/XRef>>stream
For example, we have an allowance for $940 for backsplash tile and grout. But he would not even start the demo until I had everything on site - he wanted to get in and get out without worrying about delivery issues which I understand. No but if I see that the estimate is way out of line with other estimates or with known costs then I am going to question it. Don't trust the bill. On the other hand, a budget granite can be had for about the same price as cultured marble. As long as the scope of work and budget align with the expectations, that should be more than enough. (3) Subcontracts - Identify the major cost elements for each subcontract. 9 Romford Member since 29 Jul 2011 The current Medicare manual requirement instructs Medicare contractors (carriers and MACs) to provide education to the providers and suppliers explaining the . I want an invoice as proof of the works his company did and as a security should there be any issues later on. We charge $75 an hour for itemization and your job will take between six and eight hours to compile such an estimate. Electronic invoicing and the Invoice Processing Platform (IPP). I have no desire to deal with someone who wants to hide his 500% markup on granite, for example. AV Preeminent: The highest peer rating standard. Standard Form 1034, Public Voucher for Purchases and Services other than Personal, is prescribed for used by contractors to show the amount claimed for reimbursement. They prefer to ask about your allowance and then direct you to the row of slabs that are in that price "range" without telling you specific prices. Standard Form 1035, Public Voucher for Purchases and Services other than Personal - Continuation Sheet, is prescribed for use to furnish the necessary supporting detail or additional information required by the Contracting Officer. If you ask, we aren't right for each other. Always be wary of contractors that advertise free home repair estimates or contract estimates. But even if not - if everything is on the up-and-up, and if the customer is being billed as set out by the contract or agreement to perform work, then there should be little harm in showing a customer the receipts for materials. It must be completely obvious, maybe use a large bold font. The vast majority of contractors are hardworking, trustworthy people, but just like in any profession, some individuals may overcharge you. (1) The charges for subcontracts shall be further detailed in a supporting schedule showing the major cost elements for each subcontract. It's much less important to know the allocation of $ for each of the details. If he is a reputable contractor, he would give you an itemized bill without you even having to ask. 0000003405 00000 n
Talk to their references, get a detailed quote, andbefore the project beginsa contract. (7) Travel - When travel costs exceed $2,000 per invoice period, identify by trip, the number of travelers, the duration of travel, the point of origin, destination, purpose of trip, transportation by unit price, per diem rates on daily basis and total dollars billed. I would suggest you get a quantity surveyor in to assess the values of the works done, and if its to standard, has BCO been round to inspect and sign of the works. HWn}WH@&noExl`jILx6e>Ul^dd_]31/Ib]`A$QAV.V7_-^H7W5 If a job takes a day longer i might loose a bit but thats life..Only time i charge more is for plastering as sometimes its quoted for 25mm and any more than that will cost. (nope the supplier delivers anything over 50 sheets for free), then it was well we have to go order it and on and on with inane reasons to justify the price. If a contractor can manage a 500% markup on anything in a fixed bid and still meet your bottom line (unlikely) then he's losing his shirt on another component of that bid. Invoices or requests for contract financing payment must clearly indicate the period of performance for which payment is requested. Riddled with charges and no explanation for what they are for. Notify the contractor in writing that the provider or supplier refused to submit a claim to . feedback. Final Vouchers shall be submitted if finalized rates have been received for the entire period of performance. The law does not specifically require an itemized bill. 0000004249 00000 n
Let the person quoting you the price make the suggestions first. I regret not getting better itemization from my contractor before starting the project. You in essence gave the contractor a \"blank check\" by having him do work without an estimate, proposal, or some maximum cap to cost. or an attorney's conclusion. This information should be obtained through a means which maintains subcontractor confidentiality (for example, via sealed envelopes), if the subcontractor expresses Confidential Business Information (CBI) concerns. It's a lot of work to put together a quote and so I can kind of see where they are coming from. trailer
xbbf`b``3
_m
As an example, company A might charge $150 for a specific part, which includes a 20% markup. Need help identifying this baby furniture item? (ii) Under this contract, the following documents are required to be submitted as an attachment to the IPP invoice: (This is a fill-in for acceptable types of required documentation, such as an SF 1034 and 1035, or an invoice/self-designed form on company letterhead that contains the required information.). What can be done to you for not paying court costs by a certain date? My markup and supplier discounts are none of theirs. Some balk at doing it, but some don't.They weren't super detailed, but for example the countertops line item said something like "natural stone counter up to $XX/sqft with basic edge detail installed with cutouts for sinks and faucets - $XXX"Some of the other line items were drywall/painting, electrical, plumbing, demo, shower door, tiling (labor and materials, excluding the tile itself), cabinetry.Whether they are itemized or not, try to get a fairly detailed quote for the work being done. If you drag your feet on paying, your contractor may become frustrated and file a lien against your home. If you have a written contract with your contractor or even a text exchange, look back at your agreement. Also, as a contractor you can screw yourself by giving out to much information. This includes the costs that our AHS warranty covers. You wont get any money back, you should have got at least 3 prices, checked all their credentials, insurances, how long they have been trading and seen some of their works. 1. Do I always want a line item for materials? EPA Invoice Preparation Instructions - SF 1035. I can't remember the name, but no not just drywall. You want to be sure they're charging you what they should and find a solution where you both feel comfortable. Request for pricing and shipping - teak and glass dining table. feedback, sorry to hear of your problems, firstly you need to send him a letter by registered post asking clearly for a receipt of all the work and state a time scale for a reply(14 days is acceptable) keep a copy of your letter, if he fails to reply contact inland revenue as he is not paying tax, mention in your letter that you will do this. That is pretty much an automatic out in my book. feedback. When I did my kitchen, I purchased everything myself except the cabinets. Insert COST REIMBURSABLE - FINAL VOUCHER or INDEFINITE QUANTITY/INDEFINITE DELIVERY - FINAL VOUCHER on the final public voucher. "maybe talk to trading standards as i find it also strange how his price doubled! Don't pay cash on anything over a couple of hundred pounds without a receipt, it's not traceable. The extra is for fabricating. 0000001293 00000 n
Notable: This rating indicates that the lawyer has been recognized by a large number of their peers for strong ethical standards. Adjustment vouchers should be submitted if finalized indirect rates were received but the rates are not for the entire period of performance. Time is money. However, scanned documents are acceptable when they are part of a submission of a payment request made using Invoice Processing Platform or another electronic form authorized by the Contracting Officer. (iv) Contractor assistance with enrollment can be obtained by contacting the IPP Production Helpdesk via email at IPPCustomerSupport@fiscal.treasury.gov or by telephone at (866) 973-3131. (5) Number and Date of Order - Insert payee's name and address as in the Standard Form 1034. 97% positive The Contracting Officer may request an audit of the completion vouchers before final payment is made. A construction invoice is a document that contractors use to provide an itemized bill to an individual or company to which they have provided services and/or supplies. Now my builder is refusing to give me a detailed invoice - in fact he won't provide any invoice at all. Would you order a burger at a restaurant ask them to break down the price of the lettuce, tomato, bun, pickle, burger, ketchup, mustard and mayonnaise? (5) Voucher Number - Insert the appropriate serial number of the voucher. 0000008416 00000 n
Thankfully it does not happen often and for the most part people are reasonable but there is always the few bad apples. Enter a zip below and get matched to top-rated pros near you. 99% positive With the info you have posted, its highly unlikely you will get any official receipts/gaurantees for the work. 3 attorney answers Posted on Apr 18, 2012 Your fact pattern indicates numerous violations by the contractor, including violations of the Consumer Fraud Act, which could expose him to additional damages. This actually violated the rules governing federal bankruptcy cases, which require creditors presenting a proof of claim to provide an "itemized statement.". So that I can file a claim regarding injury that occurred on our my property under phase of construction. 3. (13) Quantity; Unit Price - Insert for supply contracts. Consider negotiating any aspects that you feel are unfair or unnecessarily expensive. Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save. feedback, its the old saying pay cheap pay twice 12000 was not a realistic quote in the first place ,afraid you will need to put this down to experience ,beware of cheap imitations. There is a cost associated with that, and when you start comparing every item to the Amazon price, he knows he will lose. These ratings indicate attorneys who are widely respected by their peers for their ethical standards and legal expertise in a specific area of practice. Answered on Jan 24th, 2013 at 10:42 PM If he is a reputable contractor, he would give you an itemized bill without you even having to ask. Work contracts include start and end dates, payment plans, and several clauses intended to protect consumers. I hope this is taken in the spirit it is given, I really don't think you and Treb are saying anything different, except that you're saying you have the right to the info necessary to justify the higher bid AFTER you've received the bid, and he's saying you should have vetted him and his work BEFORE you even asked him to bid (so you'd already know the answer - that his seams and edging will be perfect; and you should have vetted the other guy too so you'd know whether his will or won't be). Can I file a civil lawsuit myself without a help of an attorney? 2. What relationship did you agree to? Not because I want the cheapest price but because I want to justify the higher price. I would see a solicitor to be honest, legally there should be a contract, or a written/verbal agreement between you and the builder. Partnership is a great word. The manner of breakdown, e.g., task order/delivery order basis with/without separate program management, contract period will be specified in the contract instructions. What can I do? Don't ask the contractor to provide you with something that you are not willing to pay for. (5) Contractor Acquired Equipment - Identify by item the quantities, unit prices, and total dollars billed. Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers, Outdoor Lighting & Audio/Visual Specialists. I know those prices. Photo: Sam Edwards/ Caia Image / Adobe Stock. Should your contractor sue you for your nonpayment, you would certainly have defenses to the claims, given the lack of notice of the increased costs and intentional overspending. You have received finalized rates for the entire base period that encompass both fiscal years that cover the base period. If I contract to build a house for you for $50k, that's what you need to know. That is more transparent as to pricing for individual components. ________________________________________________________________.
Westrock Employee Handbook,
Military Dogs Reunited,
Icw Racing Rims Lug Nut Key,
Steve Wright In The Afternoon Characters,
Articles C
contractor refuses to provide itemized billmatt hancock parents
by hsf-admincontractor refuses to provide itemized billwhat does #ll mean when someone dies
Come Celebrate our Journey of 50 years of serving all people and from all walks of life through our pictures of our celebration extravaganza!...
contractor refuses to provide itemized billi've never found nikolaos or i killed nikolaos
by hsf-admincontractor refuses to provide itemized billmalcolm rodriguez nationality
Van Mendelson Vs. Attorney General Guyana On Friday the 16th December 2022 the Chief Justice Madame Justice Roxanne George handed down an historic judgment...